Thursday, April 19, 2018

Letters to the Editor: Mason County Journal

Letters to the Editor: Mason County Journal.
Apparently, Mason County thinks that it is okay to subject its residents to potential disaster, a disaster that which if unfolded, would render a significant chunk of Mason County entirely unlivable. Recently, the residents of the Lake Limerick community have been learning of a planned 18-million-gallon septic lagoon which would be built on Webb Hill. The fact that a Determination of Non-Significance was filed shows that the county put its bottom line and the almighty dollar above its residents. In what world, is this acceptable?
For one, the emergency contingency plans for the septic lagoon are outright disastrous. According to files available publicly through the county website, the emergency spillway (and failure mechanism itself) calls for the release of the contents of that lagoon to be directed straight into Cranberry Lake.
It might be pertinent here, to discuss the significance of Cranberry Lake, and more importantly, the Lake Limerick area for which Cranberry Lake serves. In 1966, engineers with the Army Corps of Engineers constructed a dam on Cranberry Creek, an outflow of Cranberry Lake. Within a year of that dam’s construction and completion, the Lake Limerick community was established, and soon after, a nine-hole golf course constructed around the lake’s western end. In fact, the Lake Limerick Clubhouse sits just one quarter mile from where Cranberry Creek’s original path widens to become Lake Limerick.
Today, there are over 1,000 homes, over a dozen home-based businesses (including my own), a golf course, plus a grocery store, two restaurants and a firehouse that are all dependent on the water that flows out of Cranberry Lake and into Lake Limerick.
It doesn’t end there. The potential for unmitigated disaster - the likes of which we haven’t seen since Love Canal or the Hinkley, California environmental disaster which made Erin Brockovich a household name – are far too great to bear.
The climate of the Pacific Northwest in recent years, has seen rainfall events occurring on a more severe and more frequent basis. What used to be “100-year-floods” are occurring on an average of every fifteen to twenty years now. As a case example, on December 3, 2007, the Pacific Northwest was besieged with record-breaking rainfall after two days of intense snowfall which measured over three feet deep in parts of Mason County. Early on the morning of December 3, temperatures skyrocketed from just below freezing to well above 60 degrees – temperatures which are otherwise outright unheard of anywhere in the month of December.
The resulting rapid rise in temperature, combined with over seven inches of rain which fell in a 24-hour period, pushed the Skokomish River out of its banks to a record-shattering flow which actually broke the USGS flood gauge which sits on the south end of the Highway 101 crossing. Every mountain-fed river in the state saw similar records shatter that day. Down in Chehalis, the Chehalis River flooded and subsequently closed Interstate 5 for over a week, while engineers waited for the water to recede and to repair the damage.
It stands to reason, that the planners of this septic lagoon plan to have it at maximum capacity during the winter months, which is the reason I write this letter. Had that septic lagoon been in operation in December, 2007, it would have been overtopped and we would have been witness to an environmental and potential economic disaster that would’ve likely spelled the end of the Lake Limerick community.
And as we’ve been witnessing, climate change has been occurring at a much more rapid rate in recent years. As a former KOMO-TV WeatherWatcher for the Shelton area (and owner of my own observatory in Mason County for which I’ve been a NASA contributor), I’ve kept weather records on file for the last two and a half decades for Mason County. The incidents of rainfall which would push that lagoon over its design capacity aren’t far from becoming 10-year events. Since the Skokomish River shattered records in 2007, it has flooded significantly four times since then. In fact, the Skokomish River came close to tying that record in a 2009 event, and even later, in a 2012 event. Each of those flooding events would’ve spelled disaster for that lagoon, and all of us who happen to be downstream of it.
What’s infuriating about all of this, is that per the county’s own files, we are on our own if that disaster were to unfold. That’s what makes it even more unacceptable is the fact that the county seems to have “fast-tracked” the approval and application process on this. Again, I ask, in what world is this ever acceptable? When you have the potential to place a significant chunk of Mason County under an environmental and economic threat, the residents have a right to have their say in what goes on. They have a constitutional right to have their voices heard in this.
Furthermore, they have a right to have their say in telling the county “Not here!”
This septic lagoon is a bad idea, one in which must be stopped.
Signed
Steve Rosenow
Lake Limerick, Washington.

Letter by Janice Vocke

I am writing in opposition to the proposed Sewer Lagoon on Webb Hill in Mason County.
We live on Lake Leprechaun and I feel our water quality is at risk from this project, as well as all of Lake Limerick and Cranberry Lake. We have lived here at Lake Leprechaun on 1.3 acres of Lake Leprechaun waterfront for 15 years, and in Mason County for 32 years. Our property is a National Wildlife Federation Wildlife Habitat and it a beautiful and very peaceful place for us to swim, canoe, and enjoy living here, enjoy nature, and having our children and their families visit.

One of our sons lives and works on Cranberry Lake. My husband and I volunteer at Cranberry Lake working to help preserve that unique, pristine place. My husband recently was awarded "Volunteer Of The Year for 2017" by Cranberry Lake's Board. Cranberry Lake is over 800 acres of pristine beautiful natural beauty and is a nature preserve. People come from all over our state to study nature there. Environmental classes and studies are done there. Groups range from young children, to the elderly. A boardwalk system has been constructed there and they are trying to make that part handicap accessible. Groups range from school children, to scout groups and 4-H groups, to public nature walks, to Audubon Society groups, to groups from universities. Last summer there was a university group there for 2 weeks studying Cranberry Lake. At times there are classes and workshops offered to the public. I have taken some of those classes myself. At one day-long workshop of classes we studied lake plants and weeds and we were taking samples from Cranberry Lake at different levels of the lake, then studying them, identifying them and drawing them. One of my samples from Cranberry Lake caused quite a stir among the educators there: I was confused as to what it was. It looked like a miniature Razor Clam. Yet this was a freshwater lake I got it out of. One of the instructors exclaimed that it was a type of freshwater mussel that they thought was extinct!! We quickly and very gently lowered it back into the lake. Then marveled that we had been privileged to see such a rarity amongst nature! Water quality is a big part of what makes Cranberry Lake special. It must be preserved.
The proposed 18.2 million gallon sewage containment lagoon that is being considered for a site on Webb Hill should not have even been considered for approval. In the event of an emergency, such as flooding and excessive rain or snow, the effluent discharge of sewage from the 18 million gallon sewage lagoon would be directed to flow down a drainage and into Cranberry Lake. Cranberry Lake is the sole source of water for the entire Lake Limerick community, and the entire reason Lake Limerick itself exists. In 1966, engineers with the Army Corps of Engineers built a dam on Cranberry Creek, an outflow channel from Cranberry Lake, to construct the Lake Limerick community and the lake itself. Lake Limerick’s entire drinking water originally comes from Cranberry Lake, and then flows down through a small stretch of Cranberry Creek before it reaches Lake Limerick just one quarter of a mile from the Lake Limerick Clubhouse. Two restaurants and a golf clubhouse, plus over 1,500 homes, are served by the waters of Cranberry Lake. So an emergency like the one described above would render approximately 1,500 homes unlivable and result in the entire livelihood of our community irreparably damaged. It would destroy the health of the two lakes in which hundreds swim in each summer, and destroy recreational fishing in one of the county’s finest man-made lakes, as well as our little Lake Leprechaun.
Events like the flooding I have described have happened before here in Mason County, about 10 years ago, and they will happen again. I believe the question isn't "IF", but "WHEN?". Since science shows us climate change is occurring, we will have wetter winters and that means that the risk is even greater for that retention lake to overflow, sending a veritable river of sewage downhill. That would result in a huge area of Mason County being polluted.
Our natural environment, water quality, and wildlife are at risk from this sewage lagoon. Also the economic livelihood of the Lake Limerick community is at risk, as well. Plus our quality of life are at risk, as well. The risks are far too great. My family want to be able to depend on these lakes being clean and unpolluted by fecal waste for generations to come.
Please stop this project now. Otherwise, I feel it is just a matter of time before this becomes a tragedy. Not IF, but WHEN ...
Sincerely,
Janice Vocke
P.O. Box 1664
Shelton, WA. 98584

Mason County BOCC this monday

Jeff Speaks about the Sewage Lagoon
Kel with the city addresses some of Jeff's concerns

Lagoon's planned outflow map


Sample post:
posted to facebook by: 

Steven Rosenow

Did a little bit of investigating to counter a claim that the lagoon's outflow must flow uphill to reach the Cranberry Lake inflow. In the process, I discovered that the planned outflow follows a channel directly out of the prairie the planned lagoon will be built in, with a topographic elevation loss of roughly 100 feet.

I overlaid a portion of the graphic contained within the county's public files, onto a 1-meter-resolution LIDAR terrain map.

Comment deadline extended to April 22nd 2018! Please write in!!




First Post / Under Construction

Under Construction


This is a placeholder post.